Behind DVUSD’s Decision to Build a New K-8 School in Norterra

new norterra school
Photo Illustration by Erin Lundeen, In&Out Publications

Editor’s Note: News of a new Norterra school was first published by North Phoenix News last week. The story below is a more in-depth look at the decision, from the Jan. 17 issue of In&Out Magazine, our sister publication.


Deer Valley Unified School District School Board voted 3-2 last week to approve a land-swap agreement allowing the district to construct a K-8 school on a parcel that’s been set aside within USAA’s Union Park residential development, under construction near 19th Avenue and Happy Valley Road.

The decision, at the board’s Jan. 8 meeting, was fueled by ongoing residential growth in the Norterra area, as well as the district’s desire to be competitive in serving as many students as possible in North Phoenix. It came after months of negotiations with USAA and just three days before a deadline that would have freed USAA to negotiate with charter or private schools for the plot.

In exchange for the 12-acre Union Park site, DVUSD will give USAA 14 acres it owns and had no intentions of developing in the near future, at 43rd Avenue and Alameda Road, about four miles away.

Funding in Place

The agreement “allows us [the district] to divest ourselves of some land we’re really not going to develop… [and] allows us to address student growth in an area where we don’t have a great plan to accommodate those students,” Jim Migliorino, deputy superintendent of fiscal and business services, told the board.

DVUSD has bond-fund authorization from a 2013 election for the construction of a new elementary school, and the agreement with USAA now obligates the district to use those funds for the new Union Park school.

No other elementary schools are planned in this area to accommodate a projected influx of 1,125 students from Union Park and other developments between Happy Valley and Dove Valley roads (part of the North Gateway Village planning district of Maricopa County) over the next five years.

Yay Votes

Three board members, Ann Ordway, Ann O’Brien, and Julie Read agreed the school is necessary to accommodate rapid student growth in the area and to alleviate overcrowding at nearby Norterra Canyon and Sonoran Foothills schools, which are both already at or near capacity, according to the most recent demographer’s projections presented to the board in May. Sonoran Foothills, which opened in fall 2015, is the most recently opened DVUSD school.

“What’s happening in North Gateway is a lot of rezoning for residential,” said newly elected board member Julie Read, who also serves on the North Gateway Village Planning Committee. “State Trust land near Sonoran Foothills School was just auctioned off to Lennar Homes,” she said. [See "Home Builder Buys 140 Acres of State Land in North Phoenix,” In&Out Magazine, Dec. 13, 2018.] She added there are lots of rezoning cases in progress for more single-family developments, townhomes and apartments.

“I don’t know if those projections were part of the 1,125 students,” Read said. “Our district has a tendency to put Band-Aids on problems… I’m trying to look at the long-term solution and I don’t want to not be prepared for growth happening in North Phoenix.”

Since Union Park will have a DVUSD school, Superintendent Curtis Finch told the board, “I’m hoping we’ll be able to pull charter kids back to our system… that’s a personal mission of mine—to put some more fences around charters, so we’re competing on the same level.”

Nay Votes

Board members Darcy Tweedy and Jenny Frank voted against the proposal. Tweedy said the district already has a problem of excess capacity.

“When we look at capacity and our total student population, which has remained flat for years… and in that time, we’ve built more schools, which means we have more excess capacity, so we’re not operating as efficiently as we could be operating. If our total numbers of students isn’t changing, then our funding isn’t changing either, we’re just adding new schools and we have to find the money to maintain them.”

Tweedy also raised concerns of overbuilding schools in growth areas in the past that have aged out over time, and now those schools are under capacity. Anthem is one such area: Three of its four DVUSD elementary schools are below 80 percent capacity, with enrollment projected to continue declining in all four.

In addition, DVUSD may soon have to address a space concern in the growing western portion of the district in Peoria (near Jomax Road and 75th Avenue). Migliorino said the district may call for another bond election to build an additional elementary school sometime in the next five years.

“I have concerns that if we’re not able to pass another bond, we’re going to find ourselves in trouble in other areas of the district experiencing a lot of growth,” Frank said before casting her “no” vote. “It may be a tough sell when we’ve spent $8 million on renovating some of our older schools.”

Both Tweedy and Frank also suggested that nearby Desert Sage School could possibly handle the influx of additional students.

Terms of Agreement

USAA will take care of infrastructure and street improvements at the new school site. DVUSD will assist in getting the Alameda site rezoned residential.

DVUSD agreed to begin the design phase of the project by the time 100 Union Park homes have sold and closed, and begin construction on the school by the time 200 homes have closed. Model homes were completed last month by three builders in the community, which at buildout will consist of 1,200 single-family houses and 800 multi-family homes.

In the interim, students will attend the area’s designated schools, Esperanza Elementary and Deer Valley Middle School. Originally USAA had included a provision that students be bussed to Stetson Hills School, a higher performing school, but agreed to remove the clause during the months-long discussions with the district.


Pre-Paid Solar System = Low APS Bills

ADVERTISEMENT
A truly special property! Nestled in a tiny, private cul de sac, this contemporary renovated Bonavista has stunning mountain + city light views from the front and back of the home. 
3 BEDS + DEN | 2 BATHS | 3-CAR GARAGE | 2,039 SQFT | $435,000
41401 N MAIDSTONE Ct., Anthem Country Club
Call 623-297-2557 or CLICK TO LEARN MORE

Karen Goveia
NoPho resident Karen Goveia joined In&Out Publications in 2009 and is managing editor. Goveia is a Chicagoland native with two decades of experience in the news industry, starting as a reporter for a chain of weekly papers serving Chicago’s suburbs and later serving as managing editor within the chain.
Karen Goveia on Email

Karen Goveia

NoPho resident Karen Goveia joined In&Out Publications in 2009 and is managing editor. Goveia is a Chicagoland native with two decades of experience in the news industry, starting as a reporter for a chain of weekly papers serving Chicago’s suburbs and later serving as managing editor within the chain.

karengoveia has 94 posts and counting.See all posts by karengoveia